Dette er fjerde gang man har nådd kvartfinalen i FA-cupen, men første gang i moderne tid. Statistikken nedenfor tar for seg gangene man har nådd fjerde runde eller mer.
1884/1885
3. runde Grimsby – Lincoln 1-0
4. runde Old Carthusians – Grimsby 3-0
1887/1888
3. runde Grimsby – Lincoln City 2-0
4. runde Old Foresters – Grimsby 4-2
1907/1908
1. runde Bristol City – Grimsby 0-0
omkamp Grimsby – Bristol City 2-1
2. runde Grimsby – Carlisle 6-2
3. runde Grimsby – Crystal Palace 1-0
Kvarfinale Newcastle – Grimsby 5-1
1930/1931
3. runde Scarborough – Grimsby 1-2
4. runde Grimsby – Manchester United 1-0
5. runde Everton – Grimsby 5-3
1931/1932
3. runde Grimsby – Exeter 4-1
4. runde Grimsby – Birmingham 2-1
5. runde Liverpool – Grimsby 1-0
1932/1933
3. runde Grimsby – Portsmouth 3-2
4. runde Bolton Wanderers – Grimsby 2-1
1933/1934
3. runde Grimsby – Clapton Orient 1-0
4. runde Portsmouth – Grimsby 2-0
1935/1936
3. runde Hartlepool – Grimsby 0-0
omkamp Grimsby – Hartlepool 4-1
4. runde Port Vale – Grimsby 0-4
5. runde Grimsby – Manchester City 3-2
Kvartfinale Grimsby – Middlesbrough 3-1
Semifinale Grimsby – Arsenal 0-1, spilt hos Huddersfield Town
1936/1937
3. runde Cardiff – Grimsby 1-3
4. runde Grimsby – Walsall 5-1
5. runde Grimsby – Wolverhampton 1-1
omkamp Wolverhampton – Grimsby 6-2
1938/1939
3. runde Grimsby – Tranmere 6-0
4. runde Millwall – Grimsby 2-2
omkamp Grimsby – Millwall 3-2
5. runde Sheffield United – Grimsby 0-0
omkamp Grimsby – Sheffield United 1-0
Kvartfinale Chelsea – Grimsby 0-1
Semifinale Grimsby – Wolverhampton 0-5, spilt på Old Trafford
1946/1947
3. runde Reading – Grimsby 2-2
omkamp Grimsby – Reading 3-1
4. runde Liverpool – Grimsby 2-0
1948/1949
3. runde Grimsby – Exeter 2-1
4. runde Grimsby – Hull 2-3
1949/1950
3. runde Luton – Grimsby 3-4
4. runde Portsmouth – Grimsby 5-0
1958/1959
3. runde Grimsby – Manchester City 2-2
omkamp Manchester City – Grimsby 1-2
4. runde Nottingham Forest – Grimsby 4-1
1965/1966
1. runde Barrow – Grimsby 1-2
2. runde Barnsley – Grimsby 1-1
omkamp Grimsby – Barnsley 2-0
3. runde Grimsby – Portsmouth 0-0
omkamp Portsmouth – Grimsby 1-3
4. runde Manchester City – Grimsby 2-0
1972/1973
1. runde Grimsby – Wigan 2-1
2. runde Grimsby – Chesterfield 2-2
omkamp Chesterfield – Grimsby 0-1
3. runde Grimsby – Preston 0-0
omkamp Preston – Grimsby 0-1
4. runde Coventry – Grimsby 1-0
1981/1982
3. runde Millwall – Grimsby 1-6
4. runde Newcastle – Grimsby 1-2
5. runde QPR – Grimsby 3-1
1982/1983
3. runde Scunthorpe – Grimsby 0-0
omkamp Grimsby – Scunthorpe 2-0
4. runde Ipswich – Grimsby 2-0
1984/1985
3. runde Notts Co – Grimsby 2-2
omkamp Grimsby – Notts Co 4-2
4. runde Grimsby – Watford 1-3
1988/1989
1. runde Grimsby – Wolverhampton 1-0
2. runde Grimsby – Rotherham 3-2
3. runde Middlesbrough – Grimsby 1-2
4. runde Grimsby – Reading 1-1
omkamp Reading – Grimsby 1-2
5. runde Wimbledon – Grimsby 3-1
1992/1993
3. runde Brentford – Grimsby 0-2
4. runde Swansea – Grimsby 0-0
omkamp Grimsby – Swansea 2-0
5. runde Ipswich – Grimsby 4-0
1993/1994
3. runde Grimsby – Wigan 1-0
4. runde Grimsby – Aston Villa 1-2
1995/1996
3. runde Grimsby – Luton 7-1
4. runde West Ham – Grimsby 1-1
omkamp Grimsby – West Ham 3-0
5. runde Grimsby – Chelsea 0-0
omkamp Chelsea – Grimsby 4-1
1997/1998
1. runde Shrewsbury – Grimsby 1-1
omkamp Grimsby – Shrewsbury 4-0
2. runde Grimsby – Chesterfield 2-2
omkamp Chesterfield – Grimsby 0-2
3. runde Grimsby – Norwich 3-0
4. runde Leeds – Grimsby 2-0
1999/2000
3. runde Grimsby – Stockport 3-2
4. runde Grimsby – Bolton 0-2
2022/2023
1. runde Grimsby – Plymouth 5-1
2. runde Cambridge – Grimsby 1-2
3. runde Grimsby – Burton 1-0
4. runde Luton – Grimsby 2-2
omkamp Grimsby – Luton 3-0
5. runde Southampton – Grimsby 1-2
Kvartfinale Brighton Hove Albion – Grimsby
Stephen Wearne har meldt overgang til Gateshead. Jordan Cropper har blitt leid ut til Barnet.
